Author: yang2 » Mon 2 Jan, 2006 11:17 am
Geezer - I entirely agree with you. Crass generalisations about other nations and races are offensive and don't even have the excuse of being witty. However, my recollection (I'm sad to say), is that Mr Botting is a fellow Brit rather than an Australian). Raising the issue of cultural differences in either a serious or playful way, is perfectly acceptable, provided it is not done simply to cause offence or try to demonstrate one's own (self assessed) superiority. Genuinely witty jibes are probably OK too, because true wit always contains at least a dollop of truth in it. Being a fellow Brit I can usually see Homintern's tounge in his cheek when he is baiting people, but I can understand why others sometimes don't.
I'm not sure why Homintern and some others took against Aaron Lawrence's site so much. It's not great literature, but at least the writing isn't pretentious. If the things he is describing wern't already familiar (and easily within reach) I would have found his account interesting, helpful and probably something of an eye opener. I agree he doesn't capture anything of the spitit of Thailand or Thai people (which is perhaps what Homintern meant by his pineapple smoothie coment) but at least he doesn't litter his prose with redundant or inappropriate adjectives - and he deals mattter of factly with issues better writers simply don't cover.